The objective of this piece was to analyze and argue the level of mistrust and intolerance among religious groups, racial groups and groups of different sexual orientations in the Caribbean. It was seen that with respect to religious groups, intolerance and mistrust stem from differing beliefs among them. However, movements toward reducing levels of mistrust and intolerance are made by making allowances and exceptions for different religious groups. Furthermore, with respect to racial groups, intolerance and mistrust stem from hardships and respective disadvantages among groups during the colonial period. However, movements toward reducing levels of mistrust and intolerance are made by commemorating different racial groups as well as hybridization between the different groups. Finally, with respect to different sexual orientations, intolerance and mistrust stem from abuse endured during the period of slavery. However, slow but sure movements toward reducing levels of mistrust and intolerance are made by abolishing the buggery law. In conclusion, it can be seen that though mistrust and intolerance exists among groups in the Caribbean, there a moves being made to lower the level in which they exist.